When the World of Warcraft expansion pack "Wrath of the Lich King" was released last November, it was followed by a great deal of sanctimonious hand wringing in public online forums. Lich King includes a series of challenges which require you to torture a prisoner, sometimes with physical violence, and sometimes with chemicals that leave the prisoner unharmed.
I made a note to revisit the issue after a few months, when people had actually had a chance to play through and develop opinions, and put things in context. This morning I checked in with a friend who plays WOW and found most of my suspicions confirmed.
The torture scenarios play out within a larger context, and are part of a larger fabric of moral ambiguity and destruction. The "other people" who might misunderstand the use of torture have largely failed to appear. To date, my friend has not yet tortured anyone in real life, in the same way that he has failed to run amok with a long bow at the nearest Safeway.
Having studied up on the situation, I actually feel that Spore comes up worse than World of Warcraft in this regard. After all, Warcraft is a game set in a world at war. It's right there in the name. Read more